William J. Newman Realty Fire Island Real Estate | Real Estate Fire Island | Fire Island Realty

Latest Properties for Sale

Property Status: For Sale-Listed Exclusively with William Newman Realty

Fair Harbor, Fire Island

Ref #: S159

$885,000

3 Beds

2 Baths

Location: Bay Side

Charming cottage with guest house

View Property

Property Status: Price Reduction!!-Listed Exclusively with William Newman Realty

Fair Harbor, Fire Island

Ref #: S158

$1,345,000

4 Beds

2 Baths

Location: Bay side

Fully winterized and renovated 4 bedroom

View Property

View all Properties for Sale >

Latest Properties for Rent

Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty Exclusive

Fair Harbor, Fire Island

Ref #: R176

$9,000 per week

4 Beds

2 Baths

Location: Bay Front

Great bay and sunset views

View Property

Property Status: Available July/August 2026 Newman Realty exclusive.

Fair Harbor, Fire Island

Ref #: R175

$4,500 per week

3 Beds

1 Baths

Gorgeous space inside and out

Bay side on quiet walk

View Property

View all Properties for Rent >

Fire ISLAND Rentals

Over 40 years of excellent service, Newman Realty has the largest inventory of west-end rentals and the best service.

View Our Rentals

About WILLIAM J. NEWMAN REALTY

Why Choose William J. Newman Fire Island Real Estate Brokers? It’s always a challenge to find the right deal in real estate. Fire Island is a particularly tricky place to buy, rent and sell property. The Fire Island real estate market is unique, requiring a certain level of industry expertise, experience, and knowledge of the local area, its people, and available properties. Nothing could be more enchanting than owning your own piece of this magical island located off the southern coast of Long Island’s Suffolk County.